In "Elder Anderson," young Anderson finds himself under the watchful eye of Bishop Napoli, who believes in transforming mistakes into powerful lessons. Anderson's allure quickly becomes the talk of the Order, as both President Manwaring and Bishop Davies recognize his potential as a magnetic priest.

Having a rare connection to the priests, Anderson shares a past with Manwaring that dates back to high school. As Manwaring guides the younger man, Anderson is drawn back to the feelings he had during their school days. Once the perfect student and a gifted athlete, Anderson realizes college isn’t his destiny. Instead, he confides in Napoli, ready to surrender fully to the Order's teachings and embrace his true calling.